Brian Schatz

Mr. President, Claims · 22 wordswhen the people building AI warn us about the potential for their models to cause serious harm, we must take them seriously. Reasoning · 68 wordsAnd this is not a question of whether you like progress or even how likely you think the worst-case scenario is. This is a question of who is in charge of this technology, whether we are going to ensure that people remain in control or if--for some inexplicable reason--we are going to allow machines to rapidly and continuously get more powerful than us, knowing full well the risks. Claims · 11 wordsThe good news is that nothing is inevitable at this stage. Reasoning · 16 wordsWhat we do or don’t do right now will decide what happens next with this technology. The ask · 14 wordsAnd so Congress must not leave town without taking action to reduce catastrophic risk. Procedure · 31 wordsWe can argue about everything else later--what to do about AI’s energy use, what to do about the future of work, what to do about intellectual property, and all of that.Procedure The ask · 14 wordsBut, first--first--we need to address the risk that is right in front of us. Claims · 19 wordsI know my colleagues have proposals in this space, and I am also working on legislation with Senator Warner. Procedure · 6 wordsBut the bottom line is this: ProcedureThe ask · 5 wordsWe have to act now. Procedure · 6 wordsAnd I want to be clear, ProcedurePromise · 34 wordsif there is no movement in the coming days to seriously address this issue, Senator Warner and I will be back on here on the floor, attempting to pass bills to get this done. Positioning · 15 wordsPeople are counting on us to protect them, and there is no excuse for inaction.PositioningOff point Mr. President, Claims · 129 wordsin recent weeks, Hawaii experienced two separate hurricanes, which destroyed homes and roads, closed schools and offices, and left thousands of people in the dark. Ninety percent of the island of Kauai lost power during Hurricane Lala earlier this month--that is how extensive the damage was--and crews are still working to restore people.¹ People on Hawaii Island, meanwhile, are still picking up the pieces from Hurricane Lala last month, which damaged 267 homes; ²washed out roads, bridges, and even a cemetery; and left people without power and water. And, now, the State is bracing for yet another storm. According to the National Hurricane Center, this one could bring life-threatening, catastrophic flooding and mudslides across parts of Hawaii Island and Maui.³ It has been one storm after another this year. Thanks · 38 wordsWe grieve those who died in the storms, and, as always, we are so grateful to the neighbors, the first responders, the linemen, the State and local officials who have been working together to help people in need.Thanks Anecdote · 49 wordsIn the hours after the storm--in the hours after the storm--people brought over shovels to clear debris from streets and driveways and checked in on neighbors, while their own power was out. And in the days following, crews worked around the clock to restore power as quickly as possible.Anecdote Positioning · 18 wordsThat is what we do in Hawaii. We take care of each other. That is the aloha spirit.Positioning Promise · 27 wordsAnd as response gives way to recovery, we will do everything we can to make sure Federal support is available for as long as it is needed.Vague promise Claims · 51 wordsBut, today, I want to talk about something that I have been reluctant to raise in my 14 years in the U.S. Senate, and that is that there is a reason these destructive disasters are piling up, one after another, leaving communities exhausted and governments depleted. It is the warming planet. Reasoning · 89 wordsNow, look, when someone is sitting in the dark without power for days or worse, and they have lost a loved one or their home, they don’t want to hear about how dryer fields and warmer oceans are the culprit of their pain. And they are right. In the immediate aftermath of a disaster, our collective obligation--but especially the government’s obligation--is to set politics aside and to help, not to make a point that you always wanted to make or to say, ``I told you so,’’ but to help. Anecdote · 13 wordsAnd so I have always hesitated to talk about disasters in this context.Anecdote Reasoning · 34 wordsBut the reason for the change, the reason I feel so strongly that it is time that we name the problem, as uncomfortable as it is, is that we can’t go on like this. Claims · 129 wordsDisasters used to be an unfortunate reality you had to deal with from time to time, and now we’re getting back-to-back hurricanes on top of historic floods that dumped more than 2 trillion gallons on the State earlier this year and catastrophic fires that leveled Lahaina 3 years ago.⁴⁵ This is not normal. Now, it is true that we are in an El Nino year--and particularly a bad one at that--but this is not isolated to just this year nor is it limited to the great State of Hawaii. For 3 years in a row, now, we have had more than 20 disasters nationwide, each costing over a billion dollars in damages.⁶ And the world’s eight hottest months ever on record have all been in the last 3 years.⁷ Reasoning · 142 wordsYou can chalk that all up to being a terrible coincidence or maybe it is the weather fairy acting up; or you can trust your own eyes because we all see it and feel it.Unearned certainty You feel it when you go to the park and your kids can’t breathe because of the smoke from a wildfire that is burning hundreds of miles away. You feel it when you have to board up your windows and gather up supplies, as yet another storm approaches. You feel it when you move to a new State and find out that you can’t get home insurance anymore. You do not need a fancy science degree to understand what is happening nor do you even need to love the outdoors to want to do something about it, because we are all paying the price for our inaction. Positioning · 8 wordsAnd so what do we do about it?Positioning Reasoning · 19 wordsThe most obvious answer is to scale up clean energy and reduce pollution as aggressively as we possibly can. Procedure · 4 wordsBut let’s be clear: ProcedureClaims · 14 wordsThat will not happen overnight, and that will not stop the warming planet overnight. Reasoning · 21 wordsAnd so we need a plan to help communities to prepare for and respond to disasters in the here and now. The ask · 64 wordsWe have to improve evacuation routes. We have to harden powerlines. We have to pre-position equipment and supplies. We have to make sure that people have access to air conditioning and heating. Clearing underbrush to slow or stop the fires, building infrastructure to reduce the risk of flooding--these are the kinds of steps that we need to be taking right now to protect people. Claims · 53 wordsMost of my colleagues here know that disasters are not a partisan issue. Hurricanes and floods and tornadoes and fires do not pick and choose their targets based on how the last election went. This week, it is Hawaii. It was Texas and Indiana earlier this summer.⁸ It will be somewhere else next.Off point Aside · 9 wordsThere, but for the grace of God, go I.Aside The ask · 8 wordsAnd so we need to step up here. Claims · 15 wordsStates and localities are lurching from one disaster to the next, and they need help. Positioning · 18 wordsAnd every day Congress pretends like we don’t know what is happening, more and more people get hurt.PositioningOff point Procedure · 4 wordsI yield the floor.Procedure