Analysis · Speech on a bill · beta

Maxine Waters

607 words · 36 sentences · 43 clauses

Statement grade
B–
Average 71 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 8%Claims 26%Reasoning 5%Positioning 46%The ask 15%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 13 wordsI yield myself such time as I may consume. Let me be clear: ProcedureUnearned certaintyClaims · 33 wordsDodd-Frank has not led to bank consolidation.1 That trend began when Congress repealed Glass-Steagall almost 30 years ago.2 What Dodd-Frank has done is ensure the longest stretch of economic growth in a generation.3 Reasoning · 30 wordsThe threat to community banks is not Dodd- Frank, but it is to repeal it and return to their needless days, reckless days that led to the 2008 financial crisis. Claims · 56 wordsJust last week, we passed my bill as part of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act.4 My bill eased the requirements on new banks.5 H.R.Off point 6955, however, would set new banks up for failure. In fact, the bill undermines much of what we were trying to accomplish when we worked together in a bipartisan way. Procedure · 22 wordsWhat we have to do at this point in time is understand a provision of the housing bill that was carefully negotiated.ProcedureOff point Mr. Speaker, Positioning · 14 wordsI thought we all were supposed to be in support of the housing bill.Positioning Claims · 54 wordsEverybody raved about the greatness of it.Unearned certainty Now, 10 days after it became law, now some on the opposite side of the aisle are already trying to undo the bill.6Off point Now, this bill will actually make it easier for more, not less consolidation.No reason given The bill is bad for new banks but great for megabanks. Procedure · 5 wordsLet me just say this: ProcedurePositioning · 223 wordsWe all talk about loving community banks. I want you to know it is not the talk about loving community banks, it is action and what we do for or against them. I want you to know the big megabanks don’t even want them in their doors. They don’t even want to have those working behind the counter serving us. They have you serving from outside the bank. When you can get in touch with them, I want you to know, you have got to go through a hell of a menu to try to talk with someone that maybe in a community bank you can talk to. Do you know why we love community banks? It is because they understand the community. They know the people in the community. They work with you when you have a problem. The megabanks don’t know you, don’t care about you, don’t do anything to assist you, and hope you can’t get through their menus in order to speak with anybody.Off point I say, it is not a lot of talk about loving community banks. It is action and what you do. Now, then you come in here talking about how much you love the community banks, yet you know that you can’t get the deregulation that you are doing unless you hid behind the community banks.Positioning The ask · 54 wordsIf you love the community banks, all you have got to do is work with us to separate the regulations in a way that it does not undermine the community banks. If you want to be fair, charge all your big friends and all the big banks everything they should be charged with regulation. Positioning · 40 wordsThis is about whether or not you are going to use your power to literally undo what we have worked so hard to do to give the average person a decent chance with a bank, and that is community banks.Positioning Mr. Speaker, The ask · 31 wordsI am asking for a ``no’’ vote on this bill because, in the final analysis, I know that if you get away with these deregulations, we are going to have consolidation. Claims · 17 wordsIt will only be five banks, almost only five big banks in the country that control everything. The ask · 7 wordsI am asking for a ``no’’ vote, Procedure · 8 wordsand I reserve the balance of my time.Procedure

Analyzed on