This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Positioning · 14 wordsShe has worked so hard on this bill, and she has worked so hard.Positioning Claims · 20 wordsI don’t think it is done yet. I think she would admit that there are things that we can improve. Positioning · 5 wordsShe is an extraordinary legislator, PositioningClaims · 41 wordsand I am sure she would admit that this bill isn’t perfect and that more can be done, especially on the equity and treatment of athletes over coaches. I am sure she would say that because she said it to me. Positioning · 21 wordsThis is an extraordinary legislator on the Democratic side who has been leading this. I have reverence and respect for her.Positioning Anecdote · 53 wordsI played college football.1 I talk to college football players all the time. I go back and talk to college football teams. I am very involved in the space. I wouldn’t be here if it weren’t for being a High School All-American who got an unbelievable shot at a full scholarship at Stanford.2Anecdote Claims · 28 wordsWhat doesn’t seem to be understood by folks is that athletes right now all across this country and their organizations are begging for this bill not to pass. Positioning · 10 wordsWhat we are doing here in Congress is truly exemplary.Positioning Claims · 42 wordsWe are giving a permanent antitrust exemption that, as conservative Justices have said, is not seen in other areas of enterprise in the United States of America--rarely seen--and we are giving few rights to athletes but that of ``Oh, you can sue.’’ Procedure · 1 wordsWell, ProcedurePositioning · 22 wordsas a guy who played and who was competing for a starting tight end position, am I going to sue my school?Positioning Claims · 146 wordsI have seen all of these posts by athletes saying: You have got to be kidding me. My coaches tell me to play injured. I do that. I don’t sue them, when they are clearly not concerned about my well-being. Athletes have been winning in court, and now we are coming in and taking away their leverage, their bargaining power. We are settling issues that are still open. Hey, I would actually respect it if they said ``You know what, we are going to give a 10-year antitrust exemption and come back and revisit this,’’ but, no, they are giving it permanently. Nobody can justify to me--nobody can--as to why college coaches don’t get the exact same treatment in this bill as people who are playing on the field; why they can transfer willy-nilly; why they don’t have to disclose all of their side’s endorsement deals. Positioning · 21 wordsWhy are you treating the college kids differently than you are treating the coaches if it is all about the money?Positioning Promise · 85 wordsI am going to come down more and talk. I didn’t intend to do that today. I would like to move to a separate place in the record and talk about why, with urgency, I came down here. But as a guy who played ball, I can’t let this go without putting as much as I can on the Record. I was planning on coming down here, and I will. I will read sections of the bill and talk about why they are so outrageous, Procedure · 16 wordsbut let me get on with my remarks, separating them in the Record. Here we go.Procedure Mr. President, Claims · 35 wordsarticle II, section 3 of the Constitution gives the President power, on ``extraordinary occasions,’’ to convene both Houses of Congress.3 The last time a President used that power was Harry Truman in 1948--78 years ago.4 Positioning · 29 wordsWe find ourselves in such an extraordinary moment. We find ourselves in a moment that demands this kind of action. The safety of artificial intelligence systems demands urgent attention.Positioning The ask · 9 wordsThe President should immediately convene Congress to address it. Positioning · 32 wordsThis is not a moment for panic or despair; it is a moment for government to govern, to protect the American people, and to prepare soberly for risks before they become crises.Positioning Claims · 70 wordsPresidents have invoked this authority at moments when the stakes were extraordinarily high--from the earliest days of the Republic through periods of war, economic crisis, and national emergency. That is the purpose of this power that is spelled out in the Constitution: to bring Congress together when circumstances demand it and to give the country the full attention of its elected government. Congress will soon leave Washington for 2 months.5 Positioning · 5 wordsArtificial intelligence will not recess.Positioning Claims · 26 wordsThe technology will continue to advance, the risks will continue to evolve, and the consequences of getting this wrong will not wait for Congress to return. Positioning · 21 wordsThis should stand above petty partisanship. It should be about one thing--putting the safety and security of the American people first.Positioning Procedure · 13 wordsI want to focus on three challenges, the three challenges before us now.Procedure Reasoning · 8 wordsFirst, we must protect against potentially catastrophic harms. Claims · 50 wordsSerious people, including the researchers and leaders inside the companies developing the most advanced AI, are warning about dangerous biological or cyber capabilities and the emergence of systems that behave in ways humans cannot reliably predict or control. We do not know whether the most catastrophic scenarios will ever occur, Reasoning · 34 wordsbut when credible experts warn of consequences, this grave, responsible government does not panic, but it does not dismiss them either; it goes to work. Second, we must confront the harms happening right now. Claims · 31 wordsAmericans are already encountering AI through increasingly sophisticated scams targeting seniors and families, mass surveillance, threats to privacy, disruption in the workplace, and systems that can affect the prices people pay. Reasoning · 30 wordsThe future risks of AI demand our attention, but so do the people being harmed by it today. Third and final, we must seize the extraordinary possibilities this technology offers. Claims · 44 wordsAI could help scientists discover lifesaving drugs, detect diseases earlier, accelerate scientific breakthroughs, transform education, increase the productivity of American workers, help small businesses compete, and give millions of people access to capabilities that were once available only to those with wealth and power, Reasoning · 75 wordsbut none of these positive outcomes are possible without action by the government to make sure AI is safe, trusted by people, and that its benefits are broadly shared. AI cannot become another chapter in an old story where extraordinary new technologies create extraordinary new wealth and power for a small number of people while working Americans are asked to absorb the disruption, bear the costs, and wait patiently for the benefits to reach them. Claims · 212 wordsI have been calling for safety interventions for years. In July 2023, I wrote to the White House about the future of AI and what we should do as a country to prepare for it.6 It was clear to me then that we were seeing the early sparks of a technology that could have profound effects on our society, our economy, and our security. Back then, I advocated for rigorous predeployment testing of advanced models, independent evaluations and audits, incident reporting and investigation, supply chain security, international coordination, and the need for a careful and disciplined approach to the pace of AI development. I think, in addition, which I talked about, we should establish whistleblower protections for lab employees, strengthen requirements for securing frontier model weights, establish a National Transportation Safety Board-like entity for investigating AI incidents, prepare for the potential emergence of AI systems capable of autonomously improving themselves, preserve States’ ability to protect their own people in the absence of meaningful Federal standards, reject antitrust exemptions that hurt customers and competition, and, yes, put the brakes on the development of capabilities whose risks outrun our ability to manage them. Look, Americans feel beat down right now--forgotten--and that feeling is justified. Prices are up for rent, food, utilities. Hiring is flat. Positioning · 23 wordsWe have a government that moves too slowly to deliver what people need and corruption that moves too fast to protect the people.Positioning Claims · 21 wordsAnd now Americans are seeing multitrillion-dollar firms building technology that they say will exceed humans at all cognitive and physical tasks. Positioning · 10 wordsTheir anxiety is warranted, and it cannot be set aside.Positioning Claims · 24 wordsIt cannot be dismissed like Donald Trump is doing in calling it a hoax.7 Americans are demanding that we act. They are demanding leadership. Reasoning · 4 wordsAnd we must deliver.Vague promise Claims · 85 wordsWe have a rare convergence of early warning signs, practical options that are available, and a growing consensus for action, including among the American people, who understand what is at stake and are rightfully demanding that policymakers stand up. In my letter to the White House more than 3 years ago, I closed by emphasizing the importance of human agency, our collective responsibility to decide what role this technology should play in our lives rather than letting the technology or its developers decide for us. Reasoning · 6 wordsThat profound responsibility remains ours today. Positioning · 17 wordsI will always be a prisoner of hope. I will never let despair have the last word.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsI know how technology can lift people up. Anecdote · 17 wordsI have lived it. My dad came from humble beginnings and became one of IBM’s top salesmen.8Anecdote Reasoning · 31 wordsBut we will only unlock the promise of this technology if it is done in a democratic fashion wherein the people decide, not tech billionaires or trillionaires and not Donald Trump. Claims · 16 wordsAnd it is ridiculous that the House of Representatives decided to pack up and leave town.9 Positioning · 5 wordsAgain, AI will not recess.Positioning Reasoning · 6 wordsThese issues demand our urgent attention. The ask · 9 wordsIt is time for a special session of Congress. Procedure · 19 wordsThe time is now. The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. Hagerty). The question is on agreeing to the motion to proceed.Procedure
Analyzed on