A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 63%Reasoning 14%Promise 21%The ask 2%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. President, Claims · 192 wordsin reserving the right to object, this bill will needlessly punish the Northern Mariana Islands and significantly--or I should say further--harm its tourist economy, which is the islands’ largest source of revenue and jobs.1Logical leapThere is a current program in place.The current program requires any visitors who come to the Northern Mariana Islands through this program to undergo a two-step vetting process by the Department of Homeland Security, including having an in-person interview.2That program has already reduced visitation from the PRC from over 185,000 visitors down to 18 in 2026--not 18,000 but 18.3The purpose is to ensure that visitors do not pose any risk to the United States but allow the islands’ economy to grow.The current visa program was put in place after a long and thoughtful consultation between the United States and our territory the Northern Mariana Islands.It successfully balances both our national security needs and supports the economic vitality of the Northern Mariana Islands.The Northern Mariana Islands are more than just an American territory; they are one of our most important partners in the Pacific to actually counter China’s influence in this critical theater.Reasoning · 29 wordsWe can’t ask them to further decimate their tourism economy.This legislation, as well meaning as it is, would certainly undermine the stability of our partner and American territory.Promise · 27 wordsWe should not abolish the program.Instead, we need to ensure the Department of Homeland Security is doing sufficient screening to prevent visitation that poses a risk.Vague promiseClaims · 12 wordsThe Northern Mariana Islands do not have a voice in the Senate, 4Reasoning · 16 wordsand that is why I am objecting today in support of our partner in the Pacific.Promise · 42 wordsWhile I oppose the passage of this bill, I do stand ready to work with Senator Scott and others to support the security of our Nation in a way that does not harm the people and government of the Northern Mariana Islands.Vague promiseThe ask · 6 wordsSo I object to the request.