This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. President, Positioning · 277 wordsI think there are profound moments in the course of our 250 years when our Nation was at an inflection point, and I believe this is one of those inflection points where, as we look at the events in our Nation, we don’t just ask the question ``What is happening?’’ we have to ask the question ``Who are we becoming?’’ There are moments where this question of ``Who are we as a nation?’’ has to come with the understanding that every generation of Americans has to define themselves. This is a question right now, with the events of recent days, where we must ask that question--who are we as a nation? What do we stand for? This is a question that is larger than politics, larger than left or right, larger than immigration policy, larger than any one party. It is a question that really asks about the immense power that we entrust to our government and is that still constrained. Do we still live under a Constitution where, by our very definition as a nation, we should have accountability and transparency; that when we do things like pledge allegiance to a flag, it is not simply the banner, but it is also the values, this idea that every single life has worth. Think about these conceptions of humanity that we put forth 250 years ago--that we are all created equal. I believe this is an inflection point in our Nation that should not be normalized but should really force us to ask this question as American citizens and ask this question as Members of this body. Every life--every life--was created equally, has equal dignity, equal worth.Positioning Reasoning · 31 wordsAnd when government, our government, takes a life, there must be accountability; that is something precious in this Nation, the value of life and the responsibility of those who wield power. Positioning · 32 wordsIt is not just confidence in government that I am talking about. It is not just faith in how our laws are enforced. It really is the very idea of our Nation.Positioning Procedure · 18 wordsThat is how I want to set my remarks here because this is an inflection point in America.Procedure Positioning · 8 wordsWe are a nation that stands for something.Positioning Claims · 49 wordsOur Nation was founded on the belief that all are created equal, endowed by their Creator with inalienable rights, and among them are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. But today, I am rising because of my growing concern that we are not living up to those ideals, Positioning · 14 wordsand the consequences of that are that we are normalizing something so utterly tragic.Positioning Claims · 16 wordsTwo more people have fallen in our Nation. Two more families are grieving in our Nation. Positioning · 20 wordsAnd I refuse to believe that this is simply the cost of doing business in the United States of America.Positioning Claims · 166 wordsLast Tuesday morning, Lorenzo Salgado Araujo climbed into his work van like millions of Americans do all over our country every single workday. He wasn’t headed to a protest or a political rally. He wasn’t headed into conflict. He was headed to work. He was 52 years old.1 He was a husband, a father of American children, a man who spent decades in this country building a life, supporting his family, contributing to his community, paying taxes.2 On his way to work, Federal agents in unmarked vehicles began following his van.3 Moments later, an officer fired through the passenger side window, 4and Lorenzo stumbled from that vehicle. Agents forced him to the ground, and he died right there on the pavement.5 Yesterday morning, it happened again.8 Joan Sebastian Guerrero. He was 26 years old and also a father.6 He was authorized to work in our country, has a Social Security number.7 On his way to work, another shooting. Another grieving family. Another life, precious life, gone. Positioning · 129 wordsI stand here today because I am deeply worried about something so fundamental to our country that is now in crisis. I worry that we are becoming accustomed to things that should horrify us, that we are becoming so exhausted, so polarized, so overwhelmed that another death just becomes another headline, another investigation, another news cycle, another family left to grieve. The greatest danger to democracy is not simply injustice; it is when injustice no longer shocks us, no longer moves us, no longer compels us to meet that injustice. It is a poverty--a poverty of empathy, a poverty of concern. It is a tragedy that in the midst of tragedy, our hearts stop breaking, when outrage gives way to indifference, because indifference is where accountability goes to die.Positioning Claims · 21 wordsAnd this is not the first time. Earlier this year, Renee Good was killed, 9and Alex Pretti was killed.10 American citizens. Positioning · 9 wordsFamilies forever changed. Lives forever interrupted. And what happened?Positioning Claims · 9 wordsInvestigations were literally shut down by our Justice Department.11 Procedure · 3 wordsThink about that.Procedure Claims · 33 wordsThe highest law enforcement officers in the land shut down an investigation into those murders. Those investigations were not completed. They did not follow where the evidence led. They were simply stopped, halted. Positioning · 2 wordsJustice denied.Positioning Reasoning · 69 wordsEvery police officer--and I have worked closely with many of them-- every police officer knows that when deadly force is used, there must be scrutiny, not because we assume any guilt but because accountability protects everyone in our democracy. It protects the public; it protects the officers; it protects the confidence in the very idea of the rule of law upon which our country and our Constitution is built. Claims · 29 wordsNo badge and no police officer I know fear transparency. So many of the honorable officers that I dealt with every day as a mayor, they want the truth. Reasoning · 86 wordsIn fact, those incredible officers demand it because accountability is not the enemy of law enforcement. It is what gives law enforcement its strength and its true moral authority. It is what gives the laws of this land and those who conduct them their very legitimacy. To not investigate, scrutinize, have transparency and accountability when tragedy strikes, erodes the very foundation of our democracy. Amidst the tragedy of those depths, we see our very constitutional principles at stake, and this is where Congress has an obligation. Claims · 38 wordsRight now, we are seeing with ICE in America, this Congress appropriated billions upon billions of dollars, handing this Agency unprecedented sums of taxpayer money but also in that process allowing oversight to be stripped away, less accountability.Hidden agency Procedure · 3 wordsThink about this: ProcedureClaims · 56 wordsWe have appropriated to this one law enforcement Agency over $200 billion, more than the FBI, the ATF, the DEA, the Marshals Service, the Bureau of Prisons, Secret Service, TSA, 12and the Coast Guard combined. ICE in America has a bigger budget than those eight law enforcement organizations, billions upon billions of dollars, over $200 billion.13 Positioning · 10 wordsAnd yet what do we get? Greater accountability? Greater oversight?Positioning Claims · 38 wordsNo. We get lowering of hiring standards. We get reduced oversight. We get internal watchdogs removed or weakened.Hidden agency We get body cameras still absent, 14as we saw in these last two murders, as if we can’t afford them. Reasoning · 14 wordsMore money, more power, less accountability, less scrutiny, less oversight--this is not conservative government. Positioning · 41 wordsThe fiscal conservatives on both sides understand that you don’t shovel money toward an organization, outstripping most law enforcement Agencies in the entire United States of America, whether those that are investigating drug trafficking or insurance fraud or illegal arms smuggling.Positioning Claims · 26 wordsNo, $200 billion--the most spent for ICE--and you get less accountability for those taxpayer dollars and then when tragedy strikes, less accountability for actions of horror. Positioning · 41 wordsThis is dangerous, not just to families that are being pulled over and detained and thrown onto pavement. It is not just dangerous to the horrible deaths of the names that I have mentioned. But it is dangerous to our democracy.Positioning Procedure · 58 wordsBut perhaps those who have passed under these circumstances, we should listen to them. Perhaps we should listen to their last words. Lorenzo Salgado Araujo, his last words: Joan Sebastian Guerrero, his last words: Nicole Renee Good, her last words: Alex Pretti, perhaps words that should penetrate us now, his last words: Now, I thought about those words: ProcedureClaims · 3 words``Are you OK?’’ Positioning · 144 wordsAnd that is the question. Are we OK? Are we OK? Are we OK when fathers are killed on their way to work? Are we OK when systems of oversight have virtually disappeared?Hidden agency Are we OK when we entrust the extraordinary power, when we entrust that power and yet the people in power face less accountability to the people that put them in power? Are we, as a nation, becoming so numb that the death of law-abiding people by agents does not motivate us to ask: Why is this happening in America, under what justification? Are we shrinking from our duty as Americans to value every life and understand that injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere? I don’t think we are becoming numb, but I worry that the Senate is consciously looking away; that we are not doing our sworn constitutional duty.Positioning Claims · 15 wordsOur Founders, in their genius, decided to set up a government with checks and balances. Positioning · 71 wordsWhat happens to that government when the article I branch of the government here in the Senate does not ask questions like Alex Pretti did, does not look for answers like people are demanding, does not ask for oversight, not just over the $200 billion being spent but doesn’t ask for oversight when the most horrific imaginable thing can happen, when law-abiding people are killed? Are we not asking for answers?Positioning Claims · 8 wordsThis Senate swore an oath to the Constitution. Reasoning · 25 wordsWe have an obligation to provide checks and balances, to conduct oversight, to demand transparency, to hold the executive branch accountable when power is abused. Positioning · 24 wordsToday, we are failing in our constitutional duty. Today, we are failing our democracy. Today, we are failing families that are mourning and grieving.Positioning Procedure · 18 wordsLook, this is not an immigration speech. It is not a speech about whether we support strong borders.Procedure Claims · 5 wordsI do, unequivocally and firmly. Positioning · 21 wordsAmerica must have secure borders. It must enforce its immigration laws. America must protect all of its communities from any threats.Positioning Claims · 23 wordsThe first words of our founding document talked about forming a government of common defense and the safety and security of our communities. Reasoning · 20 wordsBut we can never ever abandon the fundamental precept that this is a democracy, and therefore we must have accountability. Positioning · 30 wordsWe are not an autocracy. We are not an authoritarian government. We are not a monarchy where we have Kings and Queens above question, above accountability, and above the law.Positioning Reasoning · 46 wordsWe are a democracy, and the very mission of this body is to hold the Executive accountable when they are taking Executive action, especially when they are using the greatest power that could be entrusted into a government that is to take lives, to kill people. Positioning · 44 wordsTo minimize that, to watch people die in our streets without accountability or transparency is a direct assault on the foundational ideals of who we are as a people. ``Are we OK,’’ he asks. Are we OK? This is the revolutionary idea of America.Positioning Claims · 38 wordsNo person, not a President, not Senators, not judges, no person is above the law--not a Federal agent in an unmarked car and undistinguished uniform with a gun in their hands firing through a window and killing someone. Positioning · 28 wordsPower without accountability is not strength. It is the beginning of tyranny. Every government is asked whether it will preserve the principles it inherited. This is our moment.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsThis is why the Constitution envisioned this body. Positioning · 15 wordsAnd yet we are failing in that duty to provide oversight, accountability, checks and balances.Positioning Claims · 17 wordsAnd the consequence is the repeated tragedy within this Agency of seeing people killed on our streets. The ask · 44 wordsWe owe these families, we owe our democracy an independent investigation. I demand that from my colleagues. I call upon an independent investigation, and I should be joined by a chorus of my colleagues with the conviction that this is not right or left. Positioning · 146 wordsThis is why we were elected in the first place and why we put our hands on our Bible and swore an oath to that Constitution. I am anguished. I am angry. This is an inflection point in our democracy, another one that seems to be coming with increasing speed and rapidity. We make this presumption that this Nation sits upon a bedrock that will never crumble. Well, I am telling you, I am not afraid of any nation outside of our own. What I am afraid of is the corrosive, cancerous corruption of a nation who swears an oath to ideals but does not fulfill them in their duty. I don’t know what to say when we have another dead person, when we are seeing people in our streets, law-abiding, loving their families, and they are asking those questions: Who are we in this Nation?Positioning The ask · 25 wordsI pray that this Senate changes course, and instead of silence they answer with a commanding conviction that we are the United States of America. Positioning · 30 wordsWe are a nation of laws; that no one, be they the President, be they a Senator, be they an officer in the street, no one is above the law.Positioning
Analyzed on