A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 3%Claims 60%The ask 6%Positioning 31%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 8 wordsI yield myself the balance of my time.ProcedureMr. Speaker, Claims · 20 wordsthe data--31 deaths or serious injuries from entanglements since 2022--comes from NOAA.1It is available to Democrats and Republicans alike.Off pointMr. Speaker, The ask · 8 wordsI urge this body to reject H.R.9436.Positioning · 81 wordsThis bill moves the goalposts and risks the extinction of an iconic whale that calls our Nation’s Atlantic waters home.Instead of taking the next 2 years to address the progress that has been made and additional policy levers that may be necessary to support a thriving lobster fishery and recover the right whale, this bill legislates blindly.It throws away momentum amongst the States, tech companies, and many fishery participants, kicking the can down the road.This is a shame.PositioningClaims · 14 wordsI recognize that fishing communities around this country are facing extreme levels of uncertainty, Positioning · 8 wordsand this administration is doing nothing to help.PositioningOff pointClaims · 19 wordsIn the lobster fishery, families who have fished these waters for generations are asking questions about what comes next.Positioning · 15 wordsH.R.9436 presents a false choice between saving a native species and protecting their livelihoods.PositioningClaims · 222 wordsThis delay would undermine massive public investment.Since 2022, Congress has devoted an estimated $280 million to right whale recovery.2We are beginning to see results from these investments.Advancing monitoring technologies have improved mapping of right whale patterns.Vessels are using trackers to avoid conflicts and, most importantly for this debate, ropeless gear now has a near-perfect retrieval success record and a critical safety feature.3The man overboard system is now open source technology for ropeless gear developers.4By removing the 2029 regulatory backstop, this bill creates a permission structure that discourages fishery participants from engaging in cooperative research to obtain the answers they say are needed.5Worse, it punishes the forward-thinking fishermen who have spent money and time transitioning their gear in good faith.Lastly, the bill would extend that waiver without authorizing additional money.6By delaying action until 2035 without any new funding, NOAA would need to write rules using obsolete data from the early 2020s.7Democrats offered improvements to this bill to ensure that lobstermen and their families would get the support needed to confidently transition to this new gear, but Republicans rejected these improvements.8Our suggestions would have authorized additional Federal investments for on-demand ropeless fishing technology to ensure fishermen can keep working, while removing the deadly vertical lines that entangle, injure, and kill these endangered whales.Positioning · 38 wordsTrue leadership invests in modernizing our fisheries, not freezing our conservation laws in place while marine life pays the ultimate price.Allowing a species to go extinct on our watch is a moral failure that we cannot erase.PositioningMr. Speaker, The ask · 18 wordsI urge my colleagues to reject this dangerous precedent, stand with science, and vote ``no’’ on H.R.9436.Procedure · 8 wordsI yield back the balance of my time.Procedure