Analysis · Speech on a bill · beta

John Barrasso

982 words · 73 sentences · 88 clauses

Statement grade
F
30 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 23%Claims 65%Procedure 5%Reasoning 1%The question 4%Promise 1%The ask 1%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. President, Positioning · 12 wordsthe American people deserve a government that is open and is functioning.Positioning Claims · 42 wordsThe American people know that government shutdowns cause significant pain to them personally and harm to our Nation.Unearned certainty We have had two painful shutdowns in the last year, and the Democrats--and the Democratic leader just left the floor--have caused both of them. Positioning · 30 wordsDemocrats have proven that they are willing to make life harder for Americans, and they do it every time they shut down the government. They think it helps them politically.Positioning Claims · 43 wordsActually, that is what Senator Schumer had said in the past--because in October of 2025, Schumer and the Senate Democrats chose to shut down the entire government, shut it down for 43 days.1 That is a record--a record--in the history of our Nation.2 Procedure · 9 wordsAnd Senator Schumer actually said at the time--he said: ProcedureReasoning · 8 wordsI am not sure who the ``us’’ was. Claims · 42 wordsIt is not the American people, not the people who were suffering in the long lines at the airport, and with TSA and the flights that were canceled and people that weren’t getting paid. Every day got worse for the American people. Positioning · 43 wordsIt might have been better for Senator Schumer but not for people at home in my State and in the Presiding Officer’s. It seemed to the Democrats that the American families were just collateral damage as they tried to make a political message.Positioning Claims · 138 wordsServicemembers weren’t able to pay their mortgages, as they had to wait for their paychecks to come in. Flights canceled, airport screening lines stretched--I remember the video. They stretched for hours. Park rangers, TSA agents all missed paychecks. Democrats said it got better for them every day. Government employees living paycheck-to-paycheck had to struggle to make ends meet, to pay the bills. We saw people lining up at food banks. The American people responded and offered help to their neighbors. The Democrats said it got better for them every day. People on food assistance lost that assistance. And less than 4 months later, the Democrats did it again.3 That time, they blocked funding for the Department of Homeland Security.4 That shutdown lasted 75 days for the Department of Homeland Security.5 Democrats voted to defund America’s law enforcement Agencies. Positioning · 33 wordsThat seems to be their mantra: defund the police; get rid of ICE, get rid of Immigration and Customs Enforcement; open the borders; let anybody in. That is who that party is now, PositioningClaims · 37 wordsand we are seeing it even today in the Michigan primary, where they have radical, extreme, dangerous, scary people running and who may win primaries and have been winning primaries in the Democrat Party across the country. Positioning · 34 wordsThese are people that put the safety and security of the American people at risk. They do it because they think it may give them a political advantage. It doesn’t help the American people.Positioning Claims · 54 wordsRecall that during the last shutdown, the shutdown of the Department of Homeland Security, we in this country faced terrorist threats. In Texas, there was a man wearing clothing that said ``Property of Allah.’’6 He was arrested. He shot into a crowded restaurant, just shot into the restaurant. People were killed. ``Property of Allah.’’ Positioning · 8 wordsApparently, that is OK in some people’s minds.Positioning Claims · 33 wordsMost Americans don’t think so.Unearned certainty In Michigan, a man whose family member was tied to Hezbollah rammed a truck full of explosives into a synagogue.7 Over 100 children and their teachers were inside.8 Positioning · 6 wordsThis is the threat we face.Positioning Claims · 26 wordsBy shutting down the Department of Homeland Security, Democrats put the safety of illegal immigrants--and specifically illegal immigrant criminals--above the safety and security of American citizens. Positioning · 8 wordsThat is whom the Democrats choose to prioritize, PositioningClaims · 34 wordsand we are seeing the Democrats do that in campaign ads and in campaign speeches all across the country as the most radical of the radicals seem to be winning Democrat primaries this year. The question · 17 wordsSo the question is, Are Democrats going to choose to shut down the government a third time? Claims · 9 wordsWe were able to get on the bill yesterday. Positioning · 12 wordsThe onus is on them. The Republicans are ready to move forward.Positioning Claims · 32 wordsWe have an appropriations process. That is the way that government funding is supposed to work. Right now, the Democrats are stonewalling every single Appropriations Committee right here in the U.S. Senate, Positioning · 4 wordsand it is shameful.Positioning Claims · 16 wordsSenator Susan Collins, our colleague and friend from Maine, is the chair of the Appropriations Committee.9 Positioning · 19 wordsShe has a history of working with bipartisanship, and integrity is so much a part of her leadership style.Positioning Claims · 61 wordsDemocrats have rejected every good-faith measure that she has put forward in terms of the Appropriations Committee. Recall that when the Democrats were in charge of Congress and Joe Biden was in the White House, Senator Schumer blocked 11 of the 12 appropriations bills from even coming to the floor, even coming here for debate.10 He didn’t want any of them--none. Positioning · 17 wordsRepublicans are committed to repairing the damage that has been done to the process by the Democrats.PositioningVague promise Claims · 24 wordsSenator Collins has carefully crafted a reasonable continuing resolution. That is what we voted to get on last night.11 It keeps the government open. Procedure · 7 wordsSo that was just the first step.Procedure Promise · 6 wordsNow we have to move forward. Claims · 8 wordsWe will see what the Democrats say today. Procedure · 10 wordsHere is the choice facing every Senate Democrat this week: ProcedureClaims · 14 wordsVote to keep the government open or force the Nation into another painful shutdown. Procedure · 6 wordsWe are going to find out.Procedure Claims · 19 wordsPeople have already lived through these two painful Democrat shutdowns over the last year. People don’t want a third. Positioning · 4 wordsThey have suffered enough.Positioning Claims · 11 wordsSenator Schumer this morning said he wants to avoid a shutdown.12 The ask · 6 wordsTime for them to prove it. The question · 23 wordsThe question is, Do Democrats in this body have the courage to stand up to the extremists who have taken over their party? Procedure · 17 wordsWe are going to find out.Off point I yield the floor. I suggest the absence of a quorum.Procedure

Analyzed on