Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Richard J. Durbin

711 words · 37 sentences · 49 clauses

Statement grade
B–
Average 74 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Anecdote 10%Claims 46%Procedure 1%Positioning 22%Thanks 11%The ask 10%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. President, Anecdote · 70 wordswhen I think about the issue of public health, I remember a time in my childhood when one of my friends didn’t show up for school. I asked people: Where did she go? They shook their heads and said: Polio. When she finally returned, she couldn’t walk without heavy leg braces. I will never forget the agony I saw in her eyes. Sadly, in my childhood, that story was common.Anecdote Claims · 18 wordsFor decades, a kid could go to school healthy and be paralyzed before the end of the day. Procedure · 4 wordsBut suddenly--suddenly--it all changed.Procedure Claims · 26 wordsDr. Jonas Salk created the polio vaccine.1 Dr. Sabin came up with a form that didn’t require a needle. By 1979, polio was eradicated in America.2 Positioning · 15 wordsA disease that would strike fear in the hearts of everyone was a distant memory.Positioning Thanks · 76 wordsI think there is a special place in history reserved for researchers and scientists like Dr. Salk and Dr. Sabin, who devoted their lives to saving others--people like Norman Borlaug, Edward Jenner, Madame Marie Curie, and Albert Calmette. There is another person whose name could be on that list as well-- someone who has saved millions of lives, both in America and around the world, through his lifetime of public service. His name: Dr. Anthony Fauci.Thanks Claims · 135 wordsDr. Fauci worked for the National Institutes of Health for 54 years, 38 of which he served as Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases.3 He has advised seven Presidents, of both parties, 4and seen our Nation through countless public health crises-- from SARS to avian flu, swine flu, Zika, Ebola, and on and on. Aside from his work against COVID-19, Dr. Fauci may be best known for his work on HIV/AIDS. Dr. Fauci’s tireless efforts on HIV/AIDS, both domestically and worldwide, through the creation of PEPFAR--the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief--is the main reason why this horrible disease is no longer a death sentence. In recognition of his achievement, Dr. Fauci was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2008, our Nation’s highest civilian honor, by then-President George W.5 Bush. Positioning · 31 wordsDr. Fauci is an example of American excellence, a brilliant scientific mind, and yet the Republican Party has chosen to make this doctor who has saved countless lives a political target.Positioning Claims · 56 wordsLast week, the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs subpoenaed Dr. Fauci, in front of the Congress, for a hearing with the express goal of humiliating and vilifying him.6 For nearly 3 hours, my Republican colleagues berated, cursed, and insulted a man who has dedicated his life to protecting the health of American families. Positioning · 40 wordsThis behavior is below the dignity of the Senate. Put simply, it was an embarrassment. If my colleagues had genuine concern for America’s public health, they would turn their attention instead to the destruction wrought by this administration’s anti-science agenda.Positioning Procedure · 4 wordsListen to this rollcall.Procedure Claims · 46 wordsMeasle cases are at a 35-year high in the United States of America.7 Whooping cough has resurged.8 Our response to the hantavirus and cyclospora outbreaks has been abysmal. And hundreds of thousands of people have died due to the administration’s vaccine skepticism and public health cuts.9 The ask · 24 wordsIf my Republican colleagues want to hold hearings, perhaps they should hold one on the impact of President Trump’s cuts to NIH research funding, Claims · 32 wordswhich has slowed research into heart disease, cancer, and Alzheimer’s; or they can investigate how the FDA has lost 20 percent of its staff under this administration, deeply damaging food safety efforts.10 The ask · 34 wordsIf they were truly concerned for America’s health, they would hold hearings on the fact that ACA premiums are doubling for many families across the United States because of the Republicans’ Big Beautiful Bill.11 Claims · 15 wordsThese are the real health crises of the day--all entirely of this administration’s own making. Positioning · 54 wordsBut my Republican Senate colleagues have chosen to ignore real life-and-death issues to relitigate COVID conspiracy theories--not in an effort to find out what might have gone wrong or how to prepare for the next pandemic, instead, to try and tear down a man who has devoted his entire life to lifting others up.Positioning The ask · 14 wordsDr. Fauci deserves an apology for the way he was treated by my colleagues, Positioning · 17 wordsand the American people deserve better than the pitiful display we saw in the Senate last Wednesday.Positioning

Analyzed on