This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. President, Procedure · 2 words3 years.Procedure Claims · 209 wordsFor 3 years, the people of Sudan have lived through an unimaginable nightmare and hell: 3 years of the worst raging war on our planet, 3 years of displacement, 3 years of starvation, 3 years of children growing up surrounded by violence instead of possibility. Perhaps what is most shocking is not only the horror that is unfolding in Sudan, it is how little of the world seems to be paying attention. Twenty years ago, the horrors of Darfur captured the conscience of the international community. The world declared: Never again. Yet, today, another generation of Sudanese civilians is being terrorized while the world looks away. Since April 2023, the Sudanese Armed Forces and the Rapid Support Forces have waged an unimaginably brutal war for power.1 But it is not those fighting for power who have paid the ultimate price; it is ordinary people--mothers, fathers, children, families. This war has become the world’s worst humanitarian crisis, period.Unearned certainty Entire communities have been cut off from food and medicine and lifesaving humanitarian assistance. Large parts of the country are experiencing severe food insecurity, with some areas facing outright famine and famine-like conditions. Women, children, families, journalists, aid workers--civilians of every kind have endured horrific violations of human rights and human dignity. Procedure · 6 wordsConsider what this war has done.Procedure Claims · 47 wordsMore than 15 million people have been driven from their homes.2 More than 4 million have fled Sudan altogether.3 More than 30 million people now depend on humanitarian assistance simply to survive.4 Nearly 19 million children--roughly 90 percent of Sudan’s school-age children--have lost access to formal education.5 Procedure · 3 wordsThink about that.Procedure Reasoning · 15 wordsAn entire generation is being robbed not only of their safety but of their future. Claims · 53 wordsThe United States has determined that the Rapid Support Forces have committed war crimes, crimes against humanity, ethnic cleansing, 6and genocide.7 The Sudanese Armed Forces have also committed horrific war crimes.8 The Trump administration has maintained that the genocide determination against the RSF is correct. Two administrations. Two declarations of an ongoing genocide. Reasoning · 12 wordsNone of this, though, is inevitable. None of this war is inevitable. Claims · 72 wordsThe war is continuing because outside actors continue to arm it, continue to finance it, and continue to sustain it. Every weapon that enters Sudan prolongs this crisis and the suffering of the Sudanese people. Yet, despite the staggering scale of this crisis, the Trump administration terminated bilateral humanitarian assistance to Sudan.9 And despite the need for sustained American leadership, the Trump administration has still not appointed a Special Envoy for Sudan.10 Reasoning · 30 wordsThe people of Sudan deserve more than divided attention. They deserve more than the American public looking the other way. They deserve focused American leadership in this time of crisis. Claims · 43 wordsToday, the warning lights are flashing all over the city of El Obeid. We have seen the crisis already when it comes to El Fasher and the horrors that existed there. But now we see the pattern starting again in another major community. Procedure · 4 wordsWe know this pattern.Procedure Claims · 110 wordsFirst, roads are cut. Then humanitarian aid is blocked. Then electricity disappears. Then water disappears. Communications are shut down and disappear. Civilians are trapped. And then the killing begins. Strategically located between Darfur and Khartoum, El Obeid has become the RSF’s next major target. It is home to nearly 1 million people.11 They are at risk again. Most roads into and out of El Obeid have already been cut off. Only one major route remains, and it has already come under repeated drone attacks. Those attacks are growing more frequent and more destructive. Water systems, powerplants, telecommunications infrastructure, health facilities--the very infrastructure civilians depend on to survive is under assault. Procedure · 10 wordsWe know this story, and we know how it ends.Procedure Positioning · 36 wordsIt is a call to the conscience of all of humanity and the conscience of this country. The only question now is, Will we act before history repeats itself in this city of 1 million people?Positioning Claims · 108 wordsThe head of the United Nations Fact-Finding Mission for Sudan warned: The warning has been issued. The question is whether we will listen-- because we know what happened in El Fasher. Families were hunted down house by house. Civilians were massacred at an unimaginable rate. Women were subjected to horrific sexual abuse. Children were caught between the shelling and the starvation. Thousands and thousands were killed. People who stayed were killed. People who tried to flee were killed. And the tragedy is this: None of it came without a warning. The warning signs were there. The intelligence was there. The risk was known, but the urgency was not. Reasoning · 36 wordsWe cannot allow history to repeat itself in El Obeid, nor can we allow the violence consuming Sudan to continue simply because it has fallen from the world’s headlines--fallen or never been in the U.S. headlines. Anecdote · 143 wordsI traveled to the Chad-Sudan border. As this crisis raged, I went there to witness with my own eyes. I met humanitarian workers forced to make impossible choices because they simply did not have enough food, medicine, or resources for the overwhelming need before them. I met mothers carrying children who were obviously malnourished. I met families who had watched their loved ones be murdered. I met survivors of horrific sexual violence. I met people surviving on grass because there was simply nothing left to eat. I saw what seemed like an ocean of humanity in desperation. Those images will stay with me for a lifetime. The conversations are seared into my memory, the cries for help--not just from those who were suffering as victims but from the aid workers themselves, from Americans themselves--for all of us to do more, to pay attention.Anecdote Claims · 78 wordsEven when the United States increased humanitarian assistance under the last administration during the first 2 years of the war, the need still exceeded the resources available.12 Yet, as the crisis deepened, the new Trump administration chose to terminate or allow bilateral humanitarian programs in Sudan to expire. While the administration’s contributions of $200 million to the U.N.- managed humanitarian fund is important--it is not nothing--but it is nowhere near enough to meet the scale of this catastrophe.13 Reasoning · 18 wordsThe reality on the ground demands far more from our Nation than expressions of concern; Unearned certaintyit demands action. The ask · 43 wordsThat is why I call on the Trump administration to restore and increase lifesaving humanitarian assistance to the people of Sudan. That is why the United States and our partners must increase pressure on the outside actors who continue to fuel this conflict.Vague promise Claims · 39 wordsThat is why I introduced a bipartisan resolution calling on the United Nations Security Council to fully enforce the existing Darfur arms embargo and expand it to cover all of Sudan and hold accountable anyone who breaks that embargo.14 The ask · 46 wordsI urge my colleagues in this body to join me in supporting this effort; to not turn away from this crisis; to stand, as America has stood in past generations, and call out the crisis and answer the call of humanity; to lead to end it. Procedure · 5 wordsIt is too long overdue.Procedure The ask · 12 wordsThis administration--I demand that Donald Trump appoint a Special Envoy to Sudan. Reasoning · 56 wordsIt is required by the law of this body for him to do so, 15and the people of Sudan deserve an American diplomat whose full attention is dedicated to ending this war, not one whose focus is divided upon multiple crises. The biggest humanitarian crisis on the planet Earth demands that we have a Special Envoy. Positioning · 10 wordsIf not this, then what? If not now, then when?Positioning Reasoning · 44 wordsIf the staggering human suffering is not enough to compel action, then the growing threat to regional stability should be. But I hope we don’t act because instability threatens our interest alone, even though it does; I hope we act because humanity demands it. Positioning · 21 wordsHistory has a way of asking really difficult questions: Where were you, what did you know, and what did you do?Positioning Claims · 84 wordsNo one will be able to say that we did not know about this crisis, that we did not know children are starving by the thousands upon thousands, that we did not know civilians are being massacred at rates and levels seen nowhere else on the planet Earth. The genocide wasn’t declared by the United Nations simply or some outside Agency, our own government has declared it a genocide. And now another city of a million people stands at the edge of a catastrophe. Positioning · 81 wordsThe call of humanity now is who will act. Indifference has never saved a single life but has condemned millions. Silence has never stopped a genocide, but it has allowed them to continue. Sympathy without action is impotency and failure. The people of Sudan deserve more. They deserve our action. They deserve our focus. They deserve our urgency. They deserve a nation of people in solidarity to say: This should never exist amongst humanity. It should never exist in our world.Positioning Reasoning · 29 wordsThis is not just a call for the full weight of the international community, it is a call for who has led the international community since World War II. Positioning · 111 wordsWe have been the Nation that has answered the call on so many occasions. We have been the Nation united in our conviction that such horrors and atrocities should not exist. It has been American compassion that has led other nations to move. It has been American urgency that has led other nations to move. It has been American leadership that has helped to end crises across the world. It has risen to meet the AIDS crisis. It has risen to help people in natural disasters. We are the United States of America. The test of our values is not how much we preach them but how much we live them.Positioning Reasoning · 62 wordsThe core of the faith of our Nation is to love thy neighbor, and who is your neighbor? The people of Sudan are our neighbors. They are part of our human family. There are children and families now calling to God, but it is not up to some deity to answer that call, it is up to His children to do so. Claims · 27 wordsAnother city is in peril. The horrors that might emerge in these coming days will rage again and thousands upon thousands could die or we could act. The ask · 45 wordsLet’s not wait until another massacre to discover our conscience. Let our Nation rise to its truth. Let our Nation rise to this crisis. In this dark time, let our Nation be a light to the world. Let us act now. May we act now. Procedure · 4 wordsI yield the floor.Procedure
Analyzed on