Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Roger Marshall

901 words · 60 sentences · 82 clauses

Statement grade
A
Average 91 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 56%Promise 2%Procedure 5%Reasoning 22%The question 2%Aside 1%Positioning 3%The ask 9%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. President, Claims · 38 wordsjust 2 years ago, we were a land of open borders, crime was surging across the country, and fraud was rampant. But today, the borders are secure; crime, murder rates--a 100-year low; 1and fraudsters are going to jail. Promise · 14 wordsThat is why today I am rising to support the Protecting American Taxpayers Act. Claims · 44 wordsFor years, Washington accepted fraud as the cost of doing business. The government wrote the checks, the fraudsters cashed them, and hard- working Americans were left to foot the bill. Those same hard-working Americans knew intuitively that was driving up their cost of living.Unearned certainty Procedure · 8 wordsBut those days are coming to an end.ProcedureVague promise Claims · 47 wordsUnder President Trump, we have seen historic momentum to root out waste, fraud, and abuse across the Federal Government. For the first time in a long time, Washington is shining a flashlight on the billions of taxpayer dollars disappearing through fraud, improper payments, and outright criminal activity. Reasoning · 9 wordsNow Congress has the responsibility to finish the job. The question · 20 wordsThe American people are asking a simple question: If Washington knows where the fraud is, why aren’t we stopping it? Reasoning · 6 wordsAnd they are right to ask. Claims · 12 wordsToday, an estimated $1.4 billion is stolen from taxpayers every single day.2 Reasoning · 58 wordsThat is money that should be strengthening our military, supporting our veterans, protecting Medicare and Social Security, or reducing the debt we are leaving to our children and our grandchildren. Instead, it is ending up in the hands of organized fraud rings, scam artists, and criminals who have learned exactly where the holes in our Federal Government are. Claims · 51 wordsWe are already seeing what happens when the Federal Government makes fraud enforcement a priority. In one of the largest healthcare fraud takedowns in our Nation’s history, Federal prosecutors charged hundreds of defendants accused of submitting more than $6 billion in fraudulent claims to Medicare, Medicaid, 3and other taxpayer-funded health programs. Aside · 10 wordsAnd the best part? People are finally going to jail.Aside Claims · 22 wordsInvestigators uncovered transnational criminal organizations, fraudulent medical equipment schemes, and providers accused of billing the government for services that were never provided. Reasoning · 15 wordsThese weren’t bookkeeping mistakes; they were sophisticated efforts to steal billions from the American taxpayer. Procedure · 4 wordsThe truth is simple: ProcedureUnearned certaintyReasoning · 15 wordsFraudsters follow the money, and for too long, Washington has rolled out the welcome mat. Claims · 37 wordsThis legislation finally starts closing that door. The Protecting American Taxpayers Act is projected to save taxpayers $240 billion--that is $240 billion--by preventing fraud before it happens, recovering stolen taxpayer dollars, 4and ensuring criminals are held accountable. Reasoning · 21 wordsIt doesn’t just respond to fraud after the fact; it helps stop it before another billion dollars walks out the door. Claims · 35 wordsOne piece of this package that I am proud to see included is my WALZ Act--W-A-L-Z, the WALZ Act--named after, you guessed it, a certain Governor who allowed fraud to run rampant in his State.5 Procedure · 11 wordsThe idea behind it is about as simple as it gets: ProcedureClaims · 21 wordsDon’t pay first and ask questions later. Kansas families don’t do business that way. Small businesses don’t do business that way. Reasoning · 45 wordsIf you are remodeling your kitchen, you don’t hand the contractor every penny before a single cabinet is installed. If you are hiring someone to fix your roof, you don’t write the check before the work is finished. You pay after the job is done. Claims · 87 wordsYet that is exactly the opposite of how Washington has too often operated. For years, the Federal Government has pushed billions of dollars out the door up front with little accountability and then acted surprised when criminals disappeared with the money. My WALZ Act simply says: Federal payments should be made as reimbursements after--after--the services have actually been provided.6 That one simple reform closes one of the biggest loopholes that have allowed billions of taxpayer dollars to be stolen before they ever get the chance to disappear. Procedure · 6 wordsBut this package doesn’t stop there.Procedure Claims · 63 wordsIt claws back unused COVID funds, strengthens Treasury’s fraud detection systems, extends the statute of limitations so pandemic fraudsters can’t simply run out the clock.7 It protects our veterans from scammers. It combats emerging AI- generated fraud and gives law enforcement stronger tools to hold criminals accountable. Taken together, these reforms represent one of the strongest anti-fraud packages Congress has considered in years.Logical leap Positioning · 23 wordsMy colleagues on the other side of the aisle spent years responding to every problem the same way: throwing more money at it.Positioning Reasoning · 31 wordsWe believe the first question should be: Where is the fraud? Where is the waste? Where is the abuse? And how do we stop it before asking taxpayers for another dime? Claims · 49 wordsThis administration has created real momentum for the first time in years. We are not just talking about fraud, we are finding it, prosecuting it, and putting criminals on notice that stealing from the American taxpayer has consequences. People are already being held accountable, and more need to be. The ask · 30 wordsCongress should build on that momentum by giving law enforcement and Federal Agencies the tools they need to keep fraudsters out of our programs and behind bars where they belong.Vague promise Procedure · 6 wordsSo let’s not waste this opportunity.Procedure The ask · 50 wordsLet’s make these reforms permanent. Let’s close the loopholes once and for all. Let’s protect the taxpayers who fund the government. Let’s send a clear message that the era of easy money for fraudsters is over. I urge every one of our colleagues to support the Protecting American Taxpayers Act. Procedure · 13 wordsI yield the floor. The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. Moreno). The Senator from Louisiana.Procedure

Analyzed on